Metaphors have great power to shape our mindsets, govern our ideas, and make things crystal clear. Today, I was in a forum to discuss the strength of a movement. The metaphor of a “foundation for inclusion of people with disability” was used, and we all immediately identified with it. Every building needs a firm foundation, made of solid concrete, or strong steel sunk deep in the ground. Otherwise, we are a house built on stilts, easily swayed by a change in the weather. Good metaphor, indeed.
We immediately began to work on what those foundational concrete blocks might be…great policies, strong models, documentation proving best practice, committed staff, standards of inclusive practice (i.e. is 50% inclusive OK, or is it 80%). Great to get a handle on this, and a seemingly sensible approach.
However, a second metaphor was posed…one that struck me hard. Perhaps the foundation is not made of concrete block. Perhaps the foundation of our house of ‘inclusion’ is made of icebergs. At the tips are the visible components –policies, program models, rules, standard operating procedures, staff commitment, effective procedures…beneath sits an unseen mountain of commitments to people, values, depthful understanding, sense of purpose, history, biases, passion, world views, spiritual and societal beliefs, and desire for change. The tip is easy to formulate – just find the right model, develop the right protocol, replicate a ‘best practice’, determine the proper quality indicators, write the standards for inclusion.
And, yet, the result will, in the end, be driven by that massive, unseen, powerful part of the iceberg. I suppose what is under the tip of the iceberg will remain a mystery, by definition. By its nature, we may never know it all. However, our acknowledgement that it exists, that it is powerful, and that it drives what will in fact bloom from our efforts commands my attention today.
Thanks go to the good people at the Pennsylvania Inclusion Higher Education Consortium along with today’s thought provocateur John O’Brien for this rich discussion and where it may lead.